Mueller v. State
Appeal of trial court’s decision denying defendants’ participation in a trial diversion program. The two appellants were offered participation in a pretrial diversion program if they paid $230 in fees. Appellants were unable to pay, and the prosecution sought to remove them from the program. They filed a complaint alleging removal from the program because of their inability to pay the fees is a violation of the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution.
Holding
Payment of a fee as an absolute condition of participation in the program discriminates against indigent appellants and violates the Fourteenth Amendment. There is no rational relationship between a defendant’s guilt or innocence and his inability to pay fees.
Recommended Articles
The Economic Losses from Arrest and Conviction Records
In some states, a person must pay off all fines and fees to be eligible to seal their record. This report by the Clean Slate Initiative demonstrates a...
The Economic Losses from Arrest and Conviction Records
Joint Interim Study Commission on Court Costs
Joint Interim Study Commission on Court Costs
Local Court Fee Increases Associated with Increased Jail Detention
Local Court Fee Increases Associated with Increased Jail Detention
Calls and Conduct: The Impact of Free Communication on Prison Misconduct
Calls and Conduct: The Impact of Free Communication on Prison Misconduct
The Cost We No Longer Pay: How Fines and Fees Reform Delivered Billions in Relief for Families
The Cost We No Longer Pay: How Fines and Fees Reform Delivered Billions in Relief for Families